If you were about to be stranded on a desert island, but could choose one book to take with you, what would it be?
I would choose Watchmen by Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons. This seems an unremarkable claim until I mention the truth: Watchmen is a comic book.
Comic books are a wonderful way to tell a story. They can be read with a surface appreciation in scarcely any time at all, yet to fully appreciate them can take dozens of close and contemplative readings. For my estimation, the narrative of a good comic flows better than nearly any novel, with the imagery being captured in a glance rather than dragged out. As the old saying goes, it takes a thousand words to be worth a picture. One panel may have dialogue, facial expressions, and religious markers in the background, with a recurring motif beside it. The linearity of pure text does not capture in time and layers what a well-written and drawn comic can.
Not that there aren't drawbacks. Comics would not be my first choice for communicating technical information, not do they usually demonstrate the utter mastery of a language that is possible in novel form.
But what they can capture is an utter mastery of a culture. Watchmen is remarkable because it taps into the deep concerns and fears of its time (the 1980s) and any time: Atomic weaponry, genetic manipulation, abuse of governing power, determinism, homosexuality, justice vs. mercy, conservatism vs. liberality, ethical paradox, child abuse, fetishism, thermodynamic miracles, and the teleology of human history. The story is different from many comics in that no character is pure good or pure evil, the characters thoughts are shown through expression rather than thought bubbles, and there is a balance between the fears of ambiguity and inevitability. The images and words are seemlessly of a piece. A remarkably well written piece which I can read again and again, still finding new connections and contrasts which I had not noticed before. I have never had such an experience from a book, as once it is fully read I cannot re-read it (despite my best efforts).
I have loved comic book characters since I was a child making up my own stories for the gallant adventurers. Vigilantism fascinates me, as does the post script quotation to Watchmen (which after all is just another word for vigilantees): "Quis custodiet ipsos custodes." I think deep down I'd like to write a graphic novel one day, if I knew an artist agreeable to my ideas and mythology. The term 'graphic novel' is silly, I know, but think of it this way: graphic novel is to serial comic book as movie is to television series.
But of course, the communication of narrative in pictures, like all stories, departs from the real world eventually. As Elijah Price said, "It's allright to be afraid, David, because this part won't be like a comic book. Real life doesn't fit into little boxes that were drawn for it. "
HOW I FEEL WHEN I’M TWO WEEKS OUT FROM QUALS
9 years ago